The Definitive ADHD Sugar Experiment on Children

What would I consider a definitive experiment on the effect of Sugar on children with  ADHD?

As previously discussed in Part 1, much of the work on sugar and hyperactivity is flawed and does not translate to real life parenting. In Part 2 of this series, I discussed my 65 year relationship with Sugar, Me and ADHD. My proposed experiment on Sugar, Children and ADHD is based on real scientific evidence of the effect of sugar on the body and the way children with ADHD really behave. It is based on my 65 years of ADHD and my reaction to sugar of any type whether it’s honey, high fructose corn sugar, refined sugar or brown sugar when I binge on sugar, it is the same results every time.  (see the previous post.)

First I would select 30 controls who ares clinically screened for ADHD and do not have any symptoms of ADD or ADHD. Next I would find 30 kids who definitely have ADHD and are being medicated for the disease. All would be in the same age group, probably 10 to 12 years olds because they are naturally the wildest. Finally, if possible, I would try for a third group of kids who are clinically screened as having symptoms but the diseases is either undiagnosed or untreated.

Now the design of the experiment would be double-blind with groups split in half. Neither the observers nor the children would know which group would get sugar candy or the non sugar candy. The observers would also not know which children had ADHD diagnosed or not and which group was normal.

The experiment would be run in an area set up as a playground with swings climbing stuff etc. Each child would be fitted with a heartbeat monitor, a wrist blood pressure monitor and a number on their back and front to quickly identify the children. It would be explained to the children that they are free to sample any of four to six candies and eat as much as they want and they would be asked about which ones were their favorites.  When the children were not sampling, they could play as much as they wanted or just eat more candy.  The would be free to drink soda (sugar or sugar-free depending on the group) or water as they saw fit. This would be also monitored for each child.

There are no rules or constraints.  Some of the observers should focus on the amount consumed by each child and others on the behavior of the children.  All should act normal as some are medicated into normalcy, some have undiagnosed symptoms because they are apparently normal and the rest are normal. About every 30 minutes, the children should be seated and their blood pressure and pulse rate checked. Then they should be directed to the candy table  where they are asked which ones they tried and what their favorites are and encouraged to recheck. After that, there are again no rules and the children are free to sample more candy or play. After a couple of hours, all candy would be removed and the children would be monitored for blood pressure and heart rate for three half hour intervals and have access to water only. 

About two weeks later, the same experiment would be run again with the groups reversed so all are tested for sugar sensitivity.

I am not sure whether the ADHD children would all be hyperactive, but I would guess that for those who binged, there would be phases of increased energy, and hyperactivity without problems, followed by a crash and either passive or cranky behavior. (Can I go yet? Huh? Huh?) I am also not sure whether the Parents of the ADHD sugar group would have enough trust in scientists to return their children for the second half of the experiment.

The other possibility is for my Granddaughters to skew the test. I have ADHD and her husband does too so the probability is both girls do and depending on circumstances, there symptoms can be severe.  Both are unmedicated, but my daughter is careful about their sugar consumption and what the eat.  They have both been programmed to avoid sugar and all carbonated beverages.  The oldest one is obsessive about following the rules and when together, the little one follows her lead.   If together for this experiment, both would play until every drop of energy has been expended and then they would get disgustingly cranky on a sugar low as they would hot have eaten or drank anything but water during the experimenta period.

Not all humans are the same and not all children with ADHD are the same.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

One Response to “The Definitive ADHD Sugar Experiment on Children”

  1. The Short Term Effects of Alcohol, Protein and Spices on my Body and ADHD Mind. « The Fat Savage Transformation Says:

    […] has been discussed in three posts; junk science, my relationship with sugar and what I consider a valid experiment on the effect of sugar on children. Since I don’t eat sugar very often, except for a few times a year when I binge, it really […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: